
This offseason, NBA FanHouse will address important questions about the league. It will be a Summer of Answers. First up: the biggest draft busts of the decade.
Joe Dumars is widely recognized as one of the top executives in the NBA, and while the Pistons have been unable to get over the hump since 2004, he's done an enviable job setting up his team to remain in contention through the draft, snatching up guys like Tayshaun Prince (2003), Jason Maxiell and Amir Johnson (2005) and Rodney Stuckey and Arron Afflalo (2007) after lottery teams had passed them over.
Of course, Dumars didn't always have such a deft hand at the draft -- and I'm not just talking about a certain Serbian center who went second overall in 2004. In 2000, Dumars selected hometown hero Mateen Cleaves 14th overall out of Michigan State, passing on the likes of Hedo Turkoglu, Desmond Mason, Quentin Richardson, Morris Peterson, DeShawn Stevenson, Marko Jaric, Eduardo Najera, Eddie House and (this one hurts the most) Michael Redd.
It didn't take long for Dumars to realize his mistake (Cleaves was dealt to Sacramento after one season), and as a consolation prize he was rewarded with another lottery pick. Unfortunately, he committed an even bigger blunder by taking Rodney White ninth overall. Rodney who? Exactly.
Just one pick after White, Joe Johnson went off the board, and Richard Jefferson, Zach Randolph, Gerald Wallace, Tony Parker and Gilbert Arenas soon followed (not to mention a host of lesser names who have also enjoyed serviceable careers like Vladimir Radmanovic, Troy Murphy, Brendan Haywood, Jamaal Tinsley, Samuel Dalembert, Earl Watson and Jason Collins).
Dumars did salvage the draft by finding Mehmet Okur in the second round, but any one of those other guys I mentioned would have been a monumental improvement over White, who lasted just one year in Detroit and was out of the league completely within four years. Not many GMs can waste back-to-back lottery picks and live to draft again, but even with minimal contributions from White, the Pistons won 50 games in 2001-02 and haven't won fewer since.
Even the hardest of the hard-core Pistons fans tend to forget about what Detroit missed out on by selecting White considering that was the same summer it was one summer after (fixed) Dumars turned a gimpy Grant Hill into the franchise cornerstone Ben Wallace thanks to a sign-and-trade with the Magic. And the following year Dumars had his core in place by signing Chauncey Billups, trading for Rip Hamilton and drafting Prince. The team hasn't looked back since joining the league's elite, but still, hindsight being what it is, I can't help but wonder if this team could have squeezed more than one title out of its core if they'd passed on White and taken any of the star-caliber players drafted after him.
Other Busts of the 00's:
#2 Kwame Brown
#4 Rafael Araujo
#5 Nikoloz Tskitishvili
(Dis)Honorable Mentions





















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
8-11-2008 @ 8:47AM
Ryne Nelson said...
It's *really* tough to put White above the likes of Nikoloz Tskitishvili...at least White he played. =)
Reply
8-11-2008 @ 1:16PM
Jesse said...
You could go through every team and say this about draft pick decisions they have made one year or another. Every team makes mistakes in the draft cause nothing is a given (besides Lebron James of course) especially when you get out of the top 10 picks everything gets a lot fuzzier with projections of players.
Reply
8-11-2008 @ 11:57AM
TCO said...
As I have stated in other comments, Germany looked rather impressive. Remember how the U.S. lost in the 06 World Championships? A perfect storm hit and Germany looks every bit as capable as Greece did that year. If Germany can play a modicum of defense on the perimeter and continues their hot outside shooting they definitely have a chance, arguably a better one than Greece or Argentina, to knock the U.S. off.
That being said, I feel confident in stating that the U.S. should smoothly win the gold medal.
Reply
8-11-2008 @ 1:42PM
TruthAboutIt said...
No mention of Rod-White firing a gun out of a car window in DC?
Reply
8-11-2008 @ 6:08PM
Kazu said...
Jess's right. Keep in mind that EVERY team passed on Michael Redd and Gilbert Arenas, who were both second round picks. I think Tony Parker was picked last in the 1st round, so 29 teams passed on him. Other players that EVERY team passed on include Manu Ginoili, Ben Wallace, Carlos Boozer, Rashard Lewis, and Monta Ellis, among others. You could write this same article about every good NBA GM.
Reply
8-11-2008 @ 8:46PM
chris said...
araujo went eighth, not fourth, right in front of iguodala
Reply
8-12-2008 @ 3:19AM
KD said...
Actually, the Ben-for-Grant deal was in 2000. But that would just remind you of Mateen Cleaves.
2001 was a great offseason, though. Dumars took advantage of teams looking to avoid the luxury tax through trades, signed the Seattle SuperSonics' color commentator to coach, and introduced the States to Zelly Rebraca.
Reply