
FanHouse's Tom Ziller argues his ranking of the top 50 players in the NBA.
Let's hope the Top 50 curse doesn't spread to No. 20, no offense to the unassailable Ronnie Price. The Jazz without Deron Williams, at this point, wouldn't be close to a top five team. Just as the Hornets seem on the precipice to great things for a decade, Utah hangs around with their own stunner point guard and beefy frontcourt, waiting for Kobe to become unenamored again or the Spurs to die. And the engine that drives those hopes is the league's second-best point guard under the age of 25.
I don't compare unfavorably to Chris Paul as a diss on Williams, just as I wouldn't be demeaning Carlos Boozer to say he's no Karl Malone. Facts is facts. This shouldn't discount the unbelievable talent Williams possesses, nor the value he has become to team and league.
The best point guards in the league are insatiable shooters. In fact, the NBA's top point guards, as a class, have become better shooters than the swingmen counterparts. Billups, Nash, Paul, Williams -- all of these guys shoot better than LeBron, Kobe, Wade. It's a weird situation, given that shooting points are considered a scourge to be removed from this earthly tether. These PGs obviously don't shoot as much as the swings, but frequently enough to greatly dictate the efficacy of the offense.
Williams, for example: he shot 50.7% from the floor and almost 40% from three. Those are high marks for any position, but they absolutely blow away the league-average for PGs. This isn't the only thing that makes Williams a have and, say, Jarrett Jack a have-not. But it's a huge deal. How many guys in the NBA, D-League and Europe can run a team, set up the offense, get the ball to a post threat or an iso star? Tons!, just like the tons of quarterbacks who can call plays, throw 40 yards and run around the pocket. What separates the good QBs is the ability to read a defense and see the play unfold. Point guards? Same thing.
That skill doesn't necessarily show up in assist or turnover numbers: a good portion of PG turnovers come from receiver error, just as incompletions aren't always the QB's fault. But knowing when you, the PG, have the best shot. It's your decision, whether the keep the shot yourself and set up a teammate. It's freedom (unless a coach is calling every play). Williams, and the hot-shooting PGs like him, recognize when they have the proper lay of the land, and as such they score efficiently.
On the pick-and-roll, I'd argue a PG FGA is the safest outcome. With no passes involved, the chance for a turnover is reduced. If a PG can get off a decent shot, he should take it (unless there's a more decent shot for a teammate). This is where Williams is so good: making the right decision here. It often ends up in the hands of Boozer, but Williams is a strong and unafraid to go all the way in himself. He reads the defense. As a result, he makes good decisions and boosts his stellar shooting numbers.
Again, Williams (like the other elites) is a scoring point guard -- he averaged more than 18/game last season. But this brand of scoring PG is a whole lot different than those Starbury/Franchise types, no? Those fellows were scorers who happened to play point guard (Gilbert Arenas and Mike Bibby are other examples); Williams, Paul, Billups and Nash are point guards who can score. The priority set is much better here: get the best shot for your team, even if it's your own. It's semantics, and it never comes up in the flow of the game -- it's much more a back-end philosophy. But that philosophy is all the difference.
Williams, unfortunately, will be overshadowed by Paul's ascent in coming years. We should definitely appreciate this Billups clone, though -- he runs one of the most entertaining offenses in the league, and he's sticking around a long time.
NBA Top 50
No. 50, Andris Biedrins, Warriors




















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
9-18-2008 @ 10:40AM
ecash94 said...
Boo!
Reply
9-18-2008 @ 11:11AM
ManofSteelo said...
Deron Williams #20? Silly rabbit.
Reply
9-18-2008 @ 11:13AM
MoneyM said...
Are u serious??? You got Deron Wiliams, the second or third best point guard in the league as #20??? WTF???? Yo you need to quit this ranking business cause you suck at it. BIG TIME!!!!
Reply
9-18-2008 @ 11:23AM
Step said...
The elite point guards do shoot a better percentage but there aren't any elite one on one point guard defenders either. The great offensive swingmen however have plenty of great defenders to go up against, making it harder for them to shoot a great percentage.
I wonder how Deron Williams' future at Utah is going to shake out. If Boozer leaves as a free agent, he'd have lost a dangerous weapon that's going to hurt his numbers and the team (great wisdom!). If Boozer leaves and Utah comes down to a .500 or below team, Williams' star could dim. At the same time, for the sake of Williams' legacy and Utah's prosperity, fortune shines on them and the 2010 pick they get from the Knicks turns out to be a stud power foward or center who will be better than Boozer ever was or could be. With his new and improved partner in crime in the post, perhaps they ascend even higher into championship favorites for many years.
Then again, maybe Boozer leaves, Utah declines into mediocrity, Williams gets frustrated, Sloan retires and Williams leaves after his three contract expires after declining his option.
Reply
9-18-2008 @ 11:47AM
Ryne Nelson said...
Tom, I know I'm an Illinois homer, but this is just wrong....that is, unless Chris Paul is No. 17. :-)
Reply
9-18-2008 @ 2:01PM
lunatic_fo_ever said...
Don't kid yourself. We all know CP3 will be in the top 3 top 5 at the latest. But yeah, D-Will should at least be a top 10-15 player but... c-mon tom ranked T-Mac 29th i expected another stupid placement didn't you?
9-18-2008 @ 11:50AM
zack.marker said...
I'll wait and see what the other rankings are before I condemn this (not that I was planning on it), but I'm a tad confused with this section, seems like they're not really connected sentences:
That skill doesn't necessarily show up in assist or turnover numbers: a good portion of PG turnovers come from receiver error, just as incompletions aren't always the QB's fault. But knowing when you, the PG, have the best shot. It's your decision, whether the keep the shot yourself and set up a teammate.
Reply
9-18-2008 @ 12:11PM
adamendoza said...
Come on! Williams @ the 20?! You got to be kidding me!
Reply
9-18-2008 @ 3:14PM
David said...
Guys,
Not every start player is going to be in the top 10 or top 15.
Some people are going to get knocked out.
When this list is finished I'm guessing that it will make quite a bit of sense.
Reply
9-18-2008 @ 5:05PM
walter said...
that leaves (in no particular order):
Kobe
Lebron
Paul
Pierce
KG
Nash
Amare
Billups
Rip
Yao
Dirk
Duncan
Ginobili
Wade
DHoward
Boozer
Brand
Gasol
Joe Johnson
no Shaq or Kidd
Reply
2-03-2009 @ 8:57PM
dc said...
and chris bosh, who i'd take anyday over johnson, gasol, brand, boozer, ginobili, rip, billups, and pierce.
plus dirk's peaked, yao's overrated, i guess duncan's forever gonna be great, but how old is the guy?? does anyone else remember his twin towers thing as a rookie with robinson? what year was that even in?!
also, i love nash, but i think he's one turned ankle from being done.
Reply
9-18-2008 @ 11:16PM
Martin said...
As always, any time someone tries to rank thinks, it all depends on the relative values that person places on things. Everyone will place a different emphasis on different qualities. For example, age is a big issue. Everyone starting a team today would take Deron Williams over Nash because of his youth. But if we are only looking at next year, certainly Nash may still be playing at a slightly higher level than Williams. So, as with every such list, take it with a very large grain of salt. After all, last time I checked it was still a team game, as exemplified by Boston.
Reply
9-19-2008 @ 7:31PM
MC Welk said...
Williams: Paul ; Stockton: Kevin Johnson
Reply
9-19-2008 @ 10:13PM
walter said...
totally forgot about Bosh and Al Jefferson...who gets left off then? Rip? Joe Johnson?
Reply
9-20-2008 @ 1:04AM
Andre said...
They need to give me your job. Deron Williams should be near the top 10 no questions asked. only G since Magic to have 20-10 and shoot .50 from the field. In the clutch he is the Jazz. And judging from the list you have Boozer ranked over him which is truly ridiculous.
Reply
9-22-2008 @ 12:46PM
Joe said...
It's interesting to note that in 2004, when CP3 and Wake Forest were still ranked #1 in the nation, they came into Champaign and were dismantled by Williams and the Illini.
Believe me, I'm not trying to argue that Williams is a better PG than Paul (they are easily the best and second-best young PG's in the Association) but for one night Williams led his team more effectively than Paul could. To be honest, I think it's scary how much swagger the two of them possess on the court already. We're going to see some great battles between these 2 in the future.
Reply