
Earlier I gave you the play-by-play of the altercation that went down Wednesday night between the Suns and the Rockets. I call it a "brawl" or a "fight" for the purpose of sensationalizing the headline as much as possible, but when all was said and done, no punches were thrown and no players left the benches, so it was really just a prolonged shoving match.
You can watch it here if you like, but basically, Matt Barnes tried to go through a Rafer Alston screen -- literally -- which didn't sit well with Alston, who confronted Barnes before their teammates got involved and all hell broke loose. After the game, Matt Barnes talked about what happened and why he got things started by making sure he fought extra-hard through that screen.
"I tried to get through a screen, and I guess I was too rough for him, so he tried to retaliate," Barnes said. "It was just a bunch of pushing, I didn't think anyone should have gotten thrown out because there were no punches thrown. But the refs did what they thought was necessary."
When asked if that might have been retaliation for a hard screen the Rockets gave to Steve Nash, Barnes didn't say anything that would contradict that assertion.
"Yeah, they hit us with a couple of hard screens, so... they're not going to screen me hard, so I ran through a screen, and he didn't like it," Barnes said. "You always gotta kind of watch out for your team, especially for your star point guard. They hit Steve with a hard screen, they hit me earlier with a hard screen, so I just tried to run through his screen. I mean, the refs didn't call a foul on me initially."
When Nash was told that Barnes was basically sticking up for him, he smiled and said, "Matt's a good teammate."
I asked Barnes if he thought that maybe Alston overreacted to the initial play; he wasn't sure.
"I don't really know what he was thinking, he thinks he's tough so ... I don't know really. He ran up on me, and, it was really just a bunch of pushes. No one threw any punches, no one did anything serious. But the refs had to get control of the game so they figured throwing us out would do that."
And did Barnes feel that his actions warranted the two immediate technicals and the ejection? Predictably, he did not.
"No, I definitely didn't. I thought you had to throw a punch to get kicked out of a game, really. All I did was push him, and he pushed me, I mean, T-Mac pushed Steve all the way to the ground and didn't get thrown out of the game, so ..."
So Barnes basically admitted that he gave a little shot to Alston as retaliation for some hard screens earlier in the game. But Alston didn't seem aware of any earlier screens, and felt he was straight-up cheap-shotted by Barnes.
"He just took a cheap shot at me, Alston said. "If you look at the replay, the ref is standing there watching it. It was a dirty play, he raised his arm. Good thing he didn't connect an knock my teeth out. I was just setting a screen, we were trying to get two for one ... I don't know if he was frustrated by his game or their game or or whatever was going on, but there was no call for that. There was no call for my reaction really but sometimes, when someone goes at you like that, you just react."
It looks like the two main participants here both had their reasons for doing what they did, but the bottom line is, not much actually happened besides a couple of players getting shoved to the ground. Still, the league doesn't usually react well to altercations that involve multiple members of both teams (and that are shown on an endless loop all night long on a certain four-letter network). So, even though this wasn't a brawl by definition because there were no punches thrown, I think we'd all be pretty surprised if no one were to end up getting suspended over it.





















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
11-13-2008 @ 10:20AM
Miranda said...
This was a much better written interpretation of the event than your original "play by play."
Reply
11-13-2008 @ 11:20AM
giff said...
shaq shows what a coward he is pushing T Mac in the back to knock him down, and pushing others when they weren't looking, at least T Mac pushed Barnes to his face...but then again, the Big Ego is probably just frustrated that his presence isn't making the Suns a contender and at his age, never will.
Reply
11-13-2008 @ 7:29PM
Giles said...
Shaq pushed from the side, not the back, and not T-Mac, #12, Alston. Ming tackled T-Mac just before that. Yes, it was a cheap fore arm from Barnes, whether it was retaliation or started it, but to the body not the head. If should have been a common foul, but while it was an obvious, undisquised foul, it wasn`t a flagrant foul, and it should have been one T on Alston, maybe one more on Barnes and Alston each for the controntation, no second T on Barnes, one T each on Nash, against Alston, Mac against Nash, Shaq against whomever he push, from the side, kudos to Ming Yao for tackling Mac and getting him out of trouble. Close to how the referees assessed it, other than their calling a second T on Barnes instead of the initial foul call. Amare needs to play more like Earvin Johnson, less lazy 20 foot jumpers, more passes to O`Neal, Lopez, Amundsen under the hoop, and quicker guys cutting. His bad example lost this game though Shaq was having a decent night, a tiny flashback to a couple of years ago, when he was still good. It is Amare`s fault he isn`t making the Suns a championship contender, he never learned anything but spoon fed dunks before he left high school for the nba, so he desperately needs on the job training.
11-13-2008 @ 1:57PM
Twistoffate29 said...
TMac put Nash on the floor and was stanidnt over him, Shaq pushed TMac protecting his teammate, exactly the right thing to do. Not a Shaq fan, but he earned my respect last night.
Reply
11-13-2008 @ 6:09PM
B-Ball Know How said...
Actually.... Nash was already falling to the ground before T-Mac pushed him. Tracy just "helped" him get to his destination a little quicker!
http://deadspin.com/5085273/everybody-was-shaq-fu-fighting-
For a guy who's always given kudos for his great balance, he sure does hit the floor quick at the first sign of physical danger.
11-13-2008 @ 2:26PM
Kevin Taylor said...
Time for Shaq to find employment as a bouncer.
Reply
11-13-2008 @ 3:09PM
Zebra Hunter said...
Whatever suspensions the NBA hands out should start with the referee who was standing right there and failed to call a foul on Barnes' initial cheap shot to Alston. It is often the repeated failings of the NBA officials that cause things like this to escalate into an altercation. Until the league holds the referees as accountable for doing their jobs as it holds the players for doing theirs, games are going to be just a couple of errant elbows from a brawl.
Reply
11-13-2008 @ 3:07PM
Chester said...
I have to agree, not making that original foul call got the whole mess started!
11-13-2008 @ 3:29PM
Tommie said...
I admire how shaq showed "T-whack" that he wont let his teammate get shoved to the ground like that.... man shaq would kill t-mac
Reply
11-13-2008 @ 3:52PM
bkbubco said...
Someone snapped the waistband on someone's gym shorts and everyone got bent out of shape. Hockey players must be laughing their asses off! Whadda bunch of sissies!
Reply
11-13-2008 @ 4:59PM
Larry said...
I know Barnes from high school in CA.....some things never change with him like cheap hits. The good news now is that most of the real MEN around him are bigger than he is and they can address the cheap hits he makes, unlike when he was in high school.
Reply
11-14-2008 @ 9:16PM
rock said...
Sounds like Matt ma have fucked your shit up at DC. I do agree, a punk and him in the league is due to too much expansion.
11-13-2008 @ 5:21PM
Patch said...
That's about all Shaq is good at anymore, and he is probably too old for that kind of stuff as it is.....Patch
Reply
11-13-2008 @ 5:23PM
Judy Thomas said...
I think the Suns were pissed because they were getting their butts kicked so Barnes did that cheap shot on Alston. They are a bunch of sissies and could not stand the fire.
Go Rockets Go.
Reply
11-13-2008 @ 5:41PM
Artis Gilmore said...
Shaq the Sheriff administering justice in Nottingham!
He actually defused the situation quickly without throwing a punch, and that was obviously needed because the refs absolutely SUCK.
Reply
11-13-2008 @ 7:01PM
marco said...
Steve Nash is such a p*ssy, along with the rest of the Suns team. and no, I'm NOT a Rockets fan.
Reply
11-16-2008 @ 3:16PM
Davedream said...
boy SHAQ is at a point where he'll try anything....
there will be no resurection in PHX, remember the sun sets out west, with your career....his silly ploys/rhymes/shinanigans cost him his post w. the county police dept. they even took his badge.....
YAO & CO definitely had this game and shaq was just trying to throw guys off their game, pushing from the "rear" come on now....
Reply
11-14-2008 @ 9:09AM
Rich C. said...
Can somebody explain to me exactly why Matt Barnes is n the NBA? He pops up on teams and actually starts yet I have never seen any reason for this phenomenon.
Reply