First, a retraction of sorts: on Sunday, I bemoaned the league's suspension of Dirk Nowitzki for his swing at Matt Harpring's face in Friday's Jazz-Mavs match-up. Rules are rules, and the league had to sit Dirk for a game. It was silly to suggest that ruling had been wrong. (I will not, however, back down from my statement that Harpring is ugly. And also, the opinion at the bottom of this Jazz Notes post regarding Dirk's potential reputation as a dirty player for having the temerity to fight back against the extremely, eternally dirty Jazz is absurd and reeks of localist triumphalism.)
But since rules are indeed rules, what happened to the rules the league created last summer to discourage flopping? In May, ESPN reported that the NBA would create a fine schedule to impose on the most egregious actors in the league. Almost nothing has come from it -- not one fine announced this season, no release of the ground rules or discussion of the review procedure.
This all comes to mind because of Andrei Kirilenko's flagrant flop, shown in the clip posted Sunday. Even Vlade Divac, Manu Ginobili and Anderson Varejao rolled their eyes when they saw that fall. Clint Eastwood is jealous. (And mad, also. He hates wimpy maneuvers. And Russians, also.)
If ever a flop deserved punishment, it was this one. I understand the need to keep fists at bay, but I plea for the league to understand how discouraging modern flopping is to the sport. I daresay that without the flop, Dirk's fist doesn't come out to play.
UPDATE: A league spokesman contacted FanHouse to say that contrary to the May ESPN report, the NBA is not fining players for flops this season. The league is monitoring the trend but has told media it will not fine players this year.






















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
12-29-2008 @ 4:12PM
Mike said...
God it was satisfying to watch Harpring take that fist. Yeah, AK probably deserves a fine, but let's focus on what's important here: one of the jacka**es who plays for the Jazz finally got the fist in the face that most of the team deserves.
Reply
12-29-2008 @ 8:37PM
sven said...
Yes, it was satisfying to watch Harpring take that fist to the face. Because, he took it. Didn't wince or whine or fall to the ground like Dirk has been known to do. He didn't charge back at Dirk or anything like that. Harpring is a tough player (yes, he knows those sneaky moves that often result in a foul by the opposing team) and a man. Dirk, on the other hand, is like a spoiled child. Once he gets frustrated or doesn't like the way things are going, he crumbles. That flagrant punch the other night was just another example of that.
12-29-2008 @ 5:01PM
FilteringCraig said...
Anderson Varejao at least makes sure he takes contact before he flops to the ground. That Kirilenko move was utter garbage the other night. It is one thing to accentuate the contact in your "flop" but to create an earth-shattering flop without even being touched is another thing altogether.
Reply
12-29-2008 @ 8:44PM
sven said...
PS I love the logic that Ziller employs here and elsewhere...
If...AK gets away with an obvious flop
And..Fesenko and Harpring get away with small (see: need to slow down the video to ultra slow speeds in order to see it) pushes in the back during rebounds (something that happens dozens of times a game in the NBA)
Then...Dirk is perfectly within his right to close his fist and let loose a flailing, girlie, punch to an opposing players face.
Nice work Ziller. Journalism (and logic) and its finest.
Reply
12-29-2008 @ 11:13PM
dj kahn said...
Anyone agree with me that Pau Gasol is not only a flopper but the worst type of flopped, the kind that reacts with childish triuphalism when a foul is called as he shrieks and flops? He is soft soft soft. Just thinking about this aspect of Gasol's game reeeeeeeeally gets my ire up. Thoughts?
Reply
12-30-2008 @ 8:29AM
dj kahn said...
BTW "triumphalism" is on loan from the author. Thanks Zill-Matic
Reply
12-30-2008 @ 8:29AM
Ziller said...
You've got it, brother.