I wrote in September that perhaps there would be no worthy center to start for the West in the All-Star Game.But this isn't the way I want to see that solved. Do it on the court, not with the ballot.
When the All-Star ballot came out Tuesday, Phoenix power forward Amar'e Stoudemire strangely was listed as a center. Yes, Stoudemire has played center before, but he's started all eight games for Suns this season at power forward, with Channing Frye being the starting center.
It is true the ballot, which was selected by six media members from around the country, had to be decided upon before the season began in order to provide time for printing. But it has been apparent since at least September that Frye would Phoenix's starting center, with Stoudemire at power forward.
Yes, the crop of centers in the West is not strong, with Shaquille O'Neal having departed from Phoenix to Cleveland in the East and Houston's Yao out for the season due to injury. Still, I don't think it's proper to move players on the ballot to positions at which they don't start.
Anyhow, so much for the Lakers' Andrew Bynum or Minnesota's Al Jefferson getting the starting nod at center for the West. Stoudemire figures to win the fan voting for the Feb. 14 game in Dallas in an election that conjures up memories of Nixon over McGovern in 1972.
Omissions on the ballot were Yao and New Jersey big man Yi Jianlian, but I have no problem with either. Yao is obviously hurt, so it would have been ridiculous to have listed him -- especially because he probably would have won. As for Yi, a 9.8 scoring average last season does not guarantee inclusion on the ballot.
Of course, let's find out now if Chinese-American relations have been damaged.
It was interesting to see two centers listed on the ballot for Boston in Kendrick Perkins and Rasheed Wallace. NBA teams love to tell their fans to vote for all their players, but a Celtics fan won't be able to vote for both Perkins and Wallace or else the ballot will be tossed.Still, that was a difficult problem to solve. Wallace comes off the bench to play center and forward, and listing him at forward would have given the Celtics three forwards. Kevin Garnett and Paul Pierce are the others, and they're obviously not going anywhere.
Ballot results will show how popular guard Allen Iverson continues to be. Iverson has been named a starter in nine of the past 10 years (he was a reserve in 2007 after having been traded in December 2006 from Philadelphia to Denver). That includes last season when, with Detroit, he was one of the most unworthy players in All-Star history to get a starting nod.
But now that Iverson is squabbling with Memphis and could be sent packing, could he become the first player chosen for the All-Star Game who doesn't have a team? Probably not since it would be stunning if he is voted as a starter again, but it certainly is worth following the results.
And more surprising things have happened before in elections. Don't dead people vote in Chicago?
Plenty of complaints have been coming out of Clipperland with the ballot omissions of guard Eric Gordon and center Chris Kaman, just named Western Conference Player of the Week. I can understand Kaman, who was hurt much of last season and is on a team that has another solid center in Marcus Camby, being left off. But the Gordon omission is a tough one.
Still, it must be noted it's not easy to put together an All-Star ballot. Gordon is more deserving to be on the ballot than Minnesota's Ramon Sessions. But each team must be represented three times, and Sessions was the third man for the Timberwolves.
Chris Tomasson can be reached at tomasson@fanhouse.com and on Twitter @christomasson.
2010 NBA All-Star Ballot
Eastern
Guards
Ray Allen, Celtics
Gilbert Arenas, Wizards
Mike Bibby, Hawks
Jose Calderon, Raptors
Vince Carter, Magic
Jamal Crawford, Hawks
Chris Duhon, Knicks
Raymond Felton, Bobcats
T.J. Ford, Pacers
Ben Gordon, Pistons
Richard Hamilton, Pistons
Devin Harris, Nets
Kirk Hinrich, Bulls
Joe Johnson, Hawks
Courtney Lee, Nets
Jameer Nelson, Magic
Michael Redd, Bucks
Nate Robinson, Knicks
Rajon Rondo, Celtics
Derrick Rose, Bulls
John Salmons, Bulls
Rodney Stucky, Pistons
Dwyane Wade, Heat
Mo Williams, Cavs
Forwards
Michael Beasley, Heat
Chris Bosh, Raptors
Elton Brand, Sixers
Caron Butler, Wizards
Luol Deng, Bulls
Boris Diaw, Bobcats
Kevin Garnett, Celtics
Danny Granger, Pacers
Al Harrington, Knicks
Udonis Haslem, Heat
Andre Iguodala, Sixers
LeBron James, Cavs
Antawn Jamison, Wizards
David Lee, Knicks
Rashard Lewis, Magic
Troy Murphy, Pacers
Paul Pierce, Celtics
Tayshaun Prince, Pistons
Josh Smith, Hawks
Hedo Turkoglu, Raptors
Anderson Varejao, Cavs
Charlie Villanueva, Pistons
Gerald Wallace, Bobcats
Hakim Warrick, Bucks
Centers
Andrea Bargnani, Raptors
Andrew Bogut, Bucks
Tyson Chandler, Bobcats
Samuel Dalembert, Sixers
Al Horford, Hawks
Dwight Howard, Magic
Brook Lopez, Nets
Brad Miller, Bulls
Jermaine O'Neal, Heat
Shaquille O'Neal, Cavs
Kendrick Perkins, Celtics
Rasheed Wallace, Celtics
Western
Guards
Leandro Barbosa, Suns
Chauncey Billups, Nuggets
Aaron Brooks, Rockets
Kobe Bryant, Lakers
Baron Davis, Clippers
Monta Ellis, Warriors
Manu Ginobili, Spurs
Josh Howard, Mavericks
Allen Iverson, Grizzlies
Stephen Jackson, Warriors
Jason Kidd, Mavericks
Kevin Martin, Kings
O.J. Mayo, Grizzlies
Tracy McGrady, Rockets
Andre Miller, Blazers
Steve Nash, Suns
Tony Parker, Spurs
Chris Paul, Hornets
Jason Richardson, Suns
Brandon Roy, Blazers
Ramon Sessions, Wolves
Jason Terry, Mavericks
Russell Westbrook, Thunder
Deron Williams, Jazz
Forwards
LaMarcus Aldridge, Blazers
Carmelo Anthony, Nuggets
Trevor Ariza, Rockets
Ron Artest, Lakers
Carlos Boozer, Jazz
Tim Duncan, Spurs
Kevin Durant, Thunder
Pau Gasol, Lakers
Rudy Gay, Grizzlies
Jeff Green, Thunder
Blake Griffin, Clippers
Grant Hill, Suns
Richard Jefferson, Spurs
Kevin Love, Wolves
Shawn Marion, Mavericks
Kenyon Martin, Nuggets
Paul Millsap, Jazz
Dirk Nowitzki, Mavericks
Lamar Odom, Lakers
Anthony Randolph, Warriors
Luis Scola, Rockets
Jason Thompson, Kings
Al Thornton, Clippers
David West, Hornets
Centers
Andris Biedrins, Warriors
Andrew Bynum, Lakers
Marcus Camby, Clippers
Marc Gasol, Grizzlies
Spencer Hawes, Kings
Al Jefferson, Wolves
Antonio McDyess, Spurs
Nene, Nuggets
Greg Oden, Blazers
Emeka Okafor, Hornets
Mehmet Okur, Jazz
Amar'e Stoudemire, Suns
Comments (Page 1 of 1)
hopefully Kevin Martin gets voted in this year after topping 20-point season averages for years now.
and WHO IS this writer??
Allen Iverson is still top 10 in guards in the league both this year and last year, and likely always will be (saying he was UNWORTHY is a pitiful oversight on your part). Eric Gordon is good, but nowhere NEAR All-Star good yet. and Kaman is loooong removed from being the overrated all-star of a few years ago.
The Cancer SHOULD NOT be on this list. At all. He's nothing but a whiner and I am personally looking forward to his retirement soon. Its a shame such talent was given to a man with such a big ego. Eric Gordon over The Cancer any day on this list.
Eight games into the season and they are talking all stars? No wonder this sport is going to hell.
Why not vote for the all whinner stars or the all gang banger stars or the all making way too much money stars. It would be the same list.
Really Channing Frye isn't a Center. I mean Stoudemire rebounds more, shoots closer to the hoop, is the same hieght, and out weighs Frye. The only reason Frye is called a Center is because Amare has always been called a PF. In Portland they played Frye with Aldridge and Pryzbilla a couple of times, making him at the SF.
With Chris Paul, Deron Williams, Tony Parker, Steve Nash, etc. in the West, I don`t think there is any danger Allen Iverson will be selected as an all star if he stays in the West. Maybe if he shifts east again, but then he would have a team, for a while, at least. But don`t you remember, Chris, Earvin Johnson "died" of gay aids, he caught from a "woman". Proving, what, he`s a lesbian? No wonder he and Thomas had a falling out, if he cheated on Aguire and him with a woman! Next thing you know he`ll claim he had sex with his wife too. Earvin played well in the all star game, despite being retired a half season, too. If Duncan starts at forward, it would be a more grotesque travesty than Stoudamire starting at center. But Bynum is in LA, so I doubt Stoudamire will beat him out in the fan vote. But Yao might, even with a write in vote, in Mandarin! Calderon ought to win the east point spot, but I doubt he will. Wallace averaged 6 points a game in the playoffs last season. All listing him at center did was make sure Perkins couldn`t compete with Howard, Bogut, O`Neal, O`Neal, and maybe even waived little Benito Wallace, playing well for Detroit, as a write in, to be in the east top five centers.
If Stoudemire is a center, why is he listed as PF on the roster sheets? Right now, Chris Kaman is the best center in the West, with Bynum very close. But hey: isn't it a little early to start this???
I'm not a big Clipper fan but Kaman seems the obvious choice - why wasn't he even put on the list ?
If the All-stars were to be voted for who is worthy at THIS POINT of the season, then Kaman should be in, but not as a starter. Bynum should be the starter. Amare at PF, Anthony at SF, Bryant and Nash at guards. Iverson is probably expecting to get invited, and will sulk about it when he faces reality. The East would see Howard with Garnett and Pierce at Forwards, Wade and a tossup between Joe Johnson and Rondo.
Pierce starting at Forward....ya maybe if the squad was chosen only by boston homers.... come on..Lebron is killing Pierce and most other SF's in nearly every statistical category. I cant, in good conscience, allow that last rediculous post to go unnoticed.
Great article, I have been on ESPN over the recent Ray Allen comment about fan voting. this was great insight and research into why rosters boil down the way they do and I think that its a shame the way NBA teams are created and how they shut out players more often than not.